Common Law Liberty: Rethinking American Constitutionalism
Editorial Reviews
Book Description
James Stoner's first book, Common Law and Liberal Theory: Coke, Hobbes, and the Origins of American Constitutionalism, was hailed as forceful and wise . . . powerful and convincing by the American Historical Review and a stunning achievement by the Journal of Politics. In that work, which provided historical background to the Founding era, he focused on the common law almost exclusively as a mode of legal thought. He now amplifies and extends his thinking on this subject with a study that transcends such formalistic limits and reveals how constitutional law has developed since the Founding.
Common Law Liberty is a rediscovery and reassertion of the common law's central contributions to and enduring impact on American constitutional law. Stoner illuminates the common law's ties to an entire way of life, inextricably linked to the Founding and American constitutionalism, influenced by Christianity, closely connected to the development of free enterprise, and open to the influences of modern science and democracy.
Stoner delineates two common laws: one understood by the Founders and rooted in British traditions of jurisprudence and one that, thanks to jurists like Holmes and Cardozo, corrupted the first by redefining common law as mere judge-made law or judicial process, dangerously disconnected from the values and norms of the communities it serves. The latter, for Stoner, has been a disastrous development, shrouding the common law's original meaning and vitality, replacing its spirited liberty with personal license, giving far too much discretion to judges who wish to depart from tradition and precedent, and, thus, undermining our constitutional system of checks-and-balances.
In an era as morally confused as ours, Stoner argues, we at least ought to know what we've abandoned or suppressed in the name of judicial activism and the modern rights-oriented Constitution. Having lost our way, perhaps the common law, in its original sense, provides a way back, a viable alternative to the debilitating relativism of our current age.
Drawing upon themes from his first book, as well as numerous articles, papers, and lectures produced during the past decade, Stoner crystallizes and reintegrates this body of work. By applying and contrasting both understandings of the common law to specific cases--including free speech, abortion, and religious liberty--he hopes to reclaim essential principles long buried but, in his view, desperately needed to preserve the integrity of our nation's polity and its hold on our moral imagination.
From the Back Cover
Stoner understands the common law mind-set better than anyone. In reminding us of the value of that mostly lost tradition and (paradoxically) of how its remnants still shape legal decision making, he performs an extremely valuable service. A subtle, engaging, and insightful book.--Robert F. Nagel, author of Judicial Power and American Character
James Stoner again shows in Common Law Liberty why he is the preeminent expositor and proponent of ‘common law thinking' among contemporary political scientists.--Christopher Wolfe, author of The Rise of Modern Judicial Review
A provocative challenge to contemporary legal and constitutional orthodoxy.--Keith Whittington, author of Constitutional Interpretation: Textual Meaning, Original Intent, and Judicial Review
Common Law Liberty: Rethinking American Constitutionalism
Common Law Liberty: Rethinking American Constitutionalism,James R. Stoner,University Press of Kansas,0700612483,Common Law,Constitutional,Constitutional Law,General,Law,Legal Reference / Law Profession,United States
English Books:
Recommended Books